4200 SHELL RD, Sarasota, FL 34242
4200 SHELL RD, Sarasota, FL 34242
4200 SHELL RD, Sarasota, FL 34242
REQUEST A TOUR If you would like to see this home without being there in person, select the "Virtual Tour" option and your agent will contact you to discuss available opportunities.
In-PersonVirtual Tour
STACY WEINGARTEN

STACY WEINGARTEN

+1(941) 432-4141
$25,500,000
Est. payment /mo
6 Beds
6 Baths
3,721 SqFt
Save Virtual Tour

UPDATED:

Key Details

Property Type Single Family Home

Sub Type Single Family Residence

Listing Status Active

Purchase Type For Sale

Square Footage 3,721 sqft

Price per Sqft $6,852

Subdivision Fiddler Bayou

MLS Listing ID A4708604

Bedrooms 6

Full Baths 5

Half Baths 1

HOA Y/N No

Year Built 1953

Annual Tax Amount $39,627

Lot Size 2.640 Acres

Acres 2.64

Property Sub-Type Single Family Residence

Source Stellar MLS

Property Description

For the first time The Higel Estate presents a rare opportunity to acquire 4200, 4189, and 4185 Shell Road, creating a 2.64-acre Gulf-front estate on Siesta Key with approximately 290ft of frontage along Sarasota Big Pass with a private beach. Rooted in the island's Old Florida character, the property brings together a collection of residences and an expanse of Gulf-front land rarely found along Sarasota's coastline.
Built in 1953, the original main residence and guest house remain nestled among mature tropical landscaping, just steps from the private beach. Across the three parcels, the scale of the assemblage creates the opportunity to envision something extraordinary. Architectural plans by MHK Architecture illustrate the potential for an approximately 14,000sqft residence, transforming the acreage into one grand coastal estate. Alternatively, the existing residence could become the centerpiece of a private multi-residence compound, with a separate conceptual plan envisioning an approximately 8,000sqft residence across the additional parcels. These plans offer a glimpse of what may be possible, while the combined acreage leaves the door open to an entirely different vision, shaped by the ambitions of its next owner.
Named after Sarasota pioneer Harry Higel, Higel Avenue holds a distinctive place in the history of Siesta Key. Today, its Gulf-front corridor remains one of the area's most coveted settings, where assembling acreage of this scale has become increasingly difficult. The Higel Estate brings together the elements that define a truly exceptional coastal offering: a meaningful stretch of Gulf frontage, a private beach, historic island character, and the rare opportunity to shape what comes next.

Location

State FL

County Sarasota

Community Fiddler Bayou

Area 34242 - Sarasota/Crescent Beach/Siesta Key

Zoning RE2

Rooms

Other Rooms Loft

Interior

Interior Features Ceiling Fans(s), Open Floorplan, Primary Bedroom Main Floor, Thermostat

Heating Electric

Cooling Other

Flooring Tile, Wood

Fireplaces Type Family Room, Living Room

Furnishings Negotiable

Fireplace true

Appliance Dishwasher, Exhaust Fan, Refrigerator, Washer

Laundry Inside

Exterior

Exterior Feature Fire Pit, Lighting, Outdoor Shower, Private Entrance, Storage

Parking Features Boat, Circular Driveway, Covered, Driveway

Fence Other

Pool Above Ground, Deck

Utilities Available Electricity Connected, Natural Gas Connected, Public, Water Connected

Waterfront Description Beach Front,Gulf/Ocean

View Y/N Yes

Water Access Yes

Water Access Desc Beach,Gulf/Ocean,Intracoastal Waterway

View Water, Beach, Gulf/Ocean - Full

Roof Type Metal

Porch Patio, Rear Porch, Wrap Around

Attached Garage false

Exposure East

Garage false

Private Pool Yes

Building

Lot Description FloodZone, In County, Landscaped, Oversized Lot, Private

Story 1

Entry Level One

Foundation Stem Wall

Lot Size Range 2 to less than 5

Sewer Other

Water See Remarks

Architectural Style Coastal, Cottage, Florida, Historic, Key West

Structure Type Wood Siding

New Construction false

Schools

Elementary Schools Phillippi Shores Elementary

Middle Schools Sarasota Middle

High Schools Sarasota High

Others

Pets Allowed Yes

Senior Community No

Ownership Fee Simple

Acceptable Financing Cash, Conventional

Membership Fee Required None

Listing Terms Cash, Conventional

Special Listing Condition None

Virtual Tour https://www.propertypanorama.com/instaview/stellar/A4708604

Read Less Info
Stellar MLS
© 2026 My Florida Regional MLS DBA Stellar MLS. All Rights Reserved.
Listed by Hailey Kendall WILLIAM RAVEIS - FLORIDA LLC

Nearby Locations

Go tour this home

4200 SHELL RD

QUICK SEARCH
More

Leave a reply

 

Name
Phone*
Message

By checking this box, I agree by electronic signature to the Electronic Disclosure Consent Agreement; to receive recurring marketing communication from KIRK & STACY WEINGARTEN, including auto-dialed calls, texts, and artificial/prerecorded voice messages (message frequency varies; data rates may apply; reply "STOP" to opt-out of texts or "HELP" for assistance); and to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy of this website. Consent not required to make a purchase. I understand that I can call to obtain direct assistance.